The Waiting City Review

THE WAITING CITY (2009)

Written and directed by Claire McCarthy

Starring Radha Mitchell, Joel Edgerton, Isabell Lucas and Samrat Chakrebarti

Ben (Edgerton) and Fiona (Mitchell) are a youngish Australian couple who travel to Calcutta to adopt a baby. Instead of a smooth well-organised process, they encounter another culture's bureaucracy and find the frustrations of waiting puts a strain on their marriage.

From the moment Ben and Fiona arrive in Calcutta, they carry with them a tension about the adoption. They are restless because their lives are on hold until they see their child and take her back home to Australia. They have waited for years and when they are forced to wait days longer than they expected, they are not mentally prepared for the increase in tension that this further delay causes.

Calcutta is utterly foreign to them, but in an attempt to gain further knowledge for their child when she gets older, they explore the city and it's culture. Fiona is also winding up a legal case she is working on, and therefore spends hours working on her laptop or Skyping her colleagues in Sydney. The serious cracks in her and Ben's relationship are revealed. And we are left wondering if the adoption will happen or even whether this couple are good candidates to raise an adopted daughter.

The plot of The Waiting City is light on incident. The journey of its characters is largely internal. However, I was fascinated by that journey. First time feature director McCarthy has created a solid and engrossing drama. Ben and Fiona's drive to have a child will be familiar to many and their bewilderment at dealing with an utterly foreign culture will also strike a chord.

To take a small and internal story and open it up enough to make a feature is a feat that many Australian independents don't achieve. McCarthy's success in doing this is due to a number of well-handled elements. The story has just enough meat on its bones to make it worth investing in emotionally. The performances of the two leads are very strong. Mitchell is often excellent in her movies, but not always in the right vehicle. The role of Fiona is perfect for her. Edgerton is a charismatic actor, who has played a number of similar-feeling roles, but the part of Ben is his best performance for a number of years. McCarthy's way of shooting Calcutta puts the audience right in the thick of things. You are not kept at a comfortable travelogue distance; rather you are thrust in the middle of the crowd and onto the street right along with Ben and Fiona.

The film's cinematographer, well known in Western Australian film circles, is Denson Baker. He was in Perth for The Waiting City's launch and later to do a master-class at the FTI. I had a brief conversation with him and mentioned how good it was to see an Australian film that worked. He, quite rightly, put aside my cultural cringe and said that he liked to think of the film as international.

This is the best way to consider it. We can be proud that a film made with Australian talent is this good, but perhaps more noteworthy is that it has the chops to be shown anywhere and doesn't rely on quirky Australian traits or our wide brown landscape as its hook. It's a character story that relies on craft and talent.

Obviously this is not a film for an audience looking for a vast tale of externalised emotions and death-defying actions concluding with giants orange fireballs in the night sky over Calcutta. This is a film of details, primal emotions and the threads that connect people, make relationships and create families. It deals with national identities and familial roles. If you like the idea of a movie where you join the dots and read what is implicit, then you could find The Waiting City very rewarding.

The film is currently screening at Luna Cinemas in Leederville. I rated it an 8/10.

Reviewed by Mr Trivia.